- I cannot conceive of my own annihilation: as soon as I start to think about what it would be like not to exist, I am thinking, which implies that I would exist (as in Descartes' Cogito ergo sum), which implies that I would not be thinking about what it is like not to exist.
- My annihilation is inconceivable (from 1).
- What cannot be conceived, cannot be.
- I cannot be annihilated (from 2 & 3).
- I survive after my death (from 4)
[The argument now proceeds on as in the argument from Survival After Death, only substituting in 'I' for 'a person,' until we get to:]- God exists.
FLAW 1: Premise 2 confuses psychological inconceivability with logical inconceivability. The sense in which I can't conceive of my own annihilation is like the sense in which I can't conceive of those whom I love may betray me—a failure of the imagination, not an impossible state of affairs. Thus Premise 2 ought to read "My annihilation is inconceivable to me.", which is a fact about what my brain can conceive, not a fact about what exists.
FLAW 2: Same as Flaw 3 from The Argument from the Survival of Death.
COMMENT: Though logically unsound, this is among the most powerful psychological impulses to believe in a soul, and an afterlife, and God. It genuinely is difficult—not to speak of disheartening— to conceive of oneself not existing!
Monday, November 23, 2009
Goldstein's arguments for a fictional god
At Edge.org, John Brockman introduces a brief excerpt from the first chapter of Rebecca Newberger Goldstein's forthcoming 2010 novel, 36 Arguments for the Existence of God: A Work of Fiction. Especially interesting in this preview, is the nonfiction appendix from the book -- it lists 36 arguments for the existence of god, and the reasons they each fail. Including "15. The Argument from the Inconceivability of Personal Annihilation":
Tuesday, November 10, 2009
Monday, November 02, 2009
Boston Atheists Report 1.16
Our end-of-October podcast (having skipped our middle-of-October session), recorded 11/1/2009. Topics: Atheists celebrate Halloween in Boston; Religious zealotry still in Salem; spirituality threatens health care reform. Roundtable: Being good without gods
Download this podcast from our website, or, look for us on iTunes!
Sources Cited:
Download this podcast from our website, or, look for us on iTunes!
Sources Cited:
- Spiritual Health Care Bills Alert (Freedom From Religion Foundation)
- Keep Nonsense Out of Health Care Reform (Ed Brayton)
- Haunted Happenings - Salem, MA Halloween
- The Last Witchfinder by James Morrow - Review
- Church burns "witchcraft" children (Daily Telegraph)
- Decomposing Humanism: Why Replace Religion?
- Does Morality Depend on God? The Problem of Circularity
- Trust your Gut? Study Explores Religion, Morality, and Trust in Authority (Science Daily)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)