Thursday, November 14, 2013

Foreigners: "American religion is weirdly prominent."

Over at Thought Catalog, Michael Koh's scraped together a list of responses by Quora.com contributors answering the question, "What couldn't you believe about America before moving here?" What's interesting is how many of the respondents were surprised by the prominence of American religiousity. Here are some of the responses having to do with religion:

  • Triya Bhattacharya, India, writes: "I always thought that America must be very laid-back about religion, like Europe, but that was not true. And one of the weirdest things I encountered was a Jewish person (in the black suit) preaching to us on the subway to believe in God, and Apocalypse or something, and giving us “Trillion dollar” notes with this stuff written on it."
  • Riona MacNarmara, Ireland, writes: "[I was surprised by] Religion being an actual thing. Prayer breakfasts in the White House. Educated people believing in creationism. The number of churches and denominations. People actually going to church." 
  • Olof Ã…kerlund, Sweden, writes: "The role of religion is much stronger here than in other Western nations. Things like creationism are usually believed by a handful of people in other places, but here it seems to be at least a force to be reckoned with." 

 For more perspectives on life in these United States from newcomers to America, visit the original thread on Quora.com.

Thursday, October 24, 2013

More links about Oprah's atheist-shaming, part 1

Upworthy.com by Adam Mordecai:
"Oprah Tells An Atheist She Believes In God. The Atheist Responds Like A Christian. Or Any Human."

Description: "I'm an atheist. PLEASE DON'T CLOSE THIS WINDOW YET! By being an atheist, I am in no way judging others' beliefs. I just lack them. Same with Diana Nyad, the world class swimmer and all-around awesome human being. We still have moral codes, just like everyone else. We just are slightly different. Which Oprah didn't think was possible. However, Oprah recovered nicely toward the end and really listened, which was a pleasant surprise. Yay for civilized conversation!"

Link: http://www.upworthy.com/oprah-tells-an-atheist-she-believes-in-god-the-atheist-responds-like-a-christian-or-any-human

*

Hindustan Times, from Asian News Service:
"Oprah Winfrey mocked by atheists for god advice"

Description: "Oprah Winfrey has come under fire from atheists after she suggested that non-believers cannot experience "awe" and "wonder" of the universe and if they do experience it, then they should believe in god."

Link: http://www.hindustantimes.com/entertainment/tabloid/oprah-winfrey-mocked-by-atheists-for-god-advice/article1-1136297.aspx

*

Secular Woman, by multiple contributors:
"Awe and Wonder and Oprah"

Description: "While Oprah almost certainly meant to try to find common ground, she did something far too many religious individuals do without thinking: rather than actually seeking common ground ... she forced atheists into her own religious paradigm." (With a list of reader-contributed answers to the question, "What makes gives atheists a sense of awe and wonder?"

Link: http://www.secularwoman.org/awe_and_wonder

*

Charisma News, by Kimberly Winston for Religious News Service:
"Why the Atheist Agenda Is Furious at Oprah"

Description: "Within a day or two of the broadcast, several prominent atheist leaders and organizations issued statements expressing disappointment with Winfrey. Most saw in the talk show host’s rejection of Nyad’s atheism what polls, studies and often their own experience tell them—that atheists are among the least trusted and least liked Americans."

Link: http://www.charismanews.com/us/41457-why-the-atheist-agenda-is-furious-at-oprah

Monday, October 21, 2013

Shaw on his religion

It's Monday, a day begging for a bit of wit to start the week off right. So enjoy this, the responses playwright George Bernard Shaw gave to a 1931 questionnaire asking about his views on religion.  (links to Slate.com)

Our Oprah ads were on CNN this weekend


The Boston Atheists social media campaign were featured on CNN.

It's great that we're seeing yet more traction with our efforts to alert Oprah Winfrey to the insensitivity of her comments about atheism. This weekend on CNN's "Faces of Faith" segment, Chris Stedman of the Humanist Community at Harvard did a fantastic job speaking to the need for dialogue across the knowledge/belief gap dividing religious and nonreligious communities in the US. A full transcript appears below.

The anchors, interestingly, were, like seemingly uneasy with or unclear as to how an atheist could experience awe and wonder. Mysteriously, the "atheist group" that demands an apology from Oprah isn't anywhere identified as the Boston Atheists! Not that we are surprised that the media would rather reach out to a Humanist representative before an atheist one, to speak about the experience of being a nontheist. 

We know we have a PR challenge ahead of us, insofar as American really do think that atheists aren't good or happy people. That fact is really at the core of Oprah's thoughtless comments.

Please continue to share the #atheistawesome tag on social media, to invite @Oprah and @OWNtv to dialogue about the issue of atheist identity. And share the images in our Boston Atheists Oprah images gallery, as featured on the Friendly Atheist blog! You can find the full set on Facebook.

Transcript of the CNN piece:

Friday, October 18, 2013

For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#12)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means inviting she invites Edwina RogersEddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@Oprah and @OWNTV, won't you tell your audience that atheists have feelings too? #atheistawesome


For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#11)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means inviting she invites Edwina RogersEddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@Oprah and @OWNTV, you've spoken up for equality so many times... how about now? #atheistawesome


For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#10)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means inviting she invites Edwina RogersEddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@Oprah and @OWNTV, when you deny someone's identity, you dehumanize them.. #atheistawesome

Thursday, October 17, 2013

For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#8)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means inviting she invites Edwina RogersEddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@Oprah and @OWNTV, any time is a good time to apologize for insensitivity. #atheistawesome
#atheistawesome

For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#7)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means inviting she invites Edwina RogersEddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@Oprah and @OWNTV, do you know how many of your viewers and readers are atheists?  #atheistawesome

For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#6)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means inviting she invites Edwina RogersEddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@Oprah and @OWNTV,  the damage done by thoughtless words can be undone with dialogue.  #atheistawesome

For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#5)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means inviting she invites Edwina RogersEddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@Oprah and @OWNTV, a lot of people were hurt when you denied your guest's atheist identity.  #atheistawesome

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#4)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means she invites Edwina RogersEddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag #atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@Oprah and @OWNTV, atheists sure can feel awe & wonder. If you don't get it, let us educate you! #atheistawesome


For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#3)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means she invites Edwina RogersEddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag #atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@OWNTV, atheists want to know if @Oprah is willing to reexamine the bias her comments showed. #atheistawesome



For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#2)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means inviting she invites Edwina RogersEddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag #atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@Oprah and @OWNTV, are you talking to anyone in the secular community? We're hoping for a response! #atheistawesome


For Oprah: Don't relabel atheists! (#1)

In response to Oprah Winfrey's biased comments against atheists in an October 2013 interview, the Boston Atheists are asking for support in asking her for an apology and some gesture of acknowledgment and affirmation toward the secular community. Whether that means inviting she invites Edwina Rogers, Eddie Izzard, and Stephen Fry for a sit-down on camera to talk about secular activism and atheist aesthetics, depends entirely on how much noise we can make about this! Please spread these images widely, and credit them to the Boston Atheists(a local affiliate of American Atheists. More will be posted in coming days, under the tag atheistawesome.

Tweet this image to the Oprah team! Suggested language:
@Oprah and @OWNTV, are you talking to anyone in the secular community? We're hoping for a response! #atheistawesome

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Oprah: "Atheists don't feel awe and wonder." Niose: (facepalm)

David Niose, President of the Secular Coalition for America (and, being a MA resident himself, one of the key supporters of the Secular Coalition for Massachusetts), has written a bang-up piece explaining why Oprah's prominence multiplies the injury of her negative view of atheism:
Oprah, exalted by so many but oblivious to the fact that she is dehumanizing atheists, does more to perpetuate negative attitudes toward nonbelievers than Pat Robertson or James Dobson ever could. The general public takes comments from Robertson and Dobson with a grain of salt – but Oprah, as a media tycoon and a beloved celebrity whose opinions are taken seriously by millions, has just confirmed that atheists are "the other," outsiders who just don't belong in the in-group. (And the evidence is clear that atheists are indeed widely, and wrongly, scorned in America. With commentary such as Oprah's, we can see why.)
Read the full piece at Psychology Today. And take a moment to tweet to Oprah or to the staff at her television network, @OWNtv... ask them when we're going to hear Oprah walking-back her comments, or when she's going to invite an atheist or several on-camera, to explore the depth and breadth of the atheist's capacity to feel awe and wonder

Thursday, August 29, 2013

Fowles on the obligation to be an atheist

In 1998, John Fowles (author of The Magus and The Aristos) was quoted in the New York Times Book Review as saying, "Being an atheist is a matter not of moral choice, but of human obligation."

(Source: WP)

Monday, August 26, 2013

Atheism in popular culture #271: "I need it to be real"

In Season One Episode 12 (2013) of the Netflix original series Orange Is the New Black", the character Piper Chapman is rebuffing another inmate who is pressuring her to concede to be baptized:
I believe in science. I believe in evolution. I believe in Nate Silver and Neil deGrasse Tyson, and Christopher Hitchens. (Although I do admit he could be a kind of an asshole.) 
I cannot get behind some supreme being who weighs in on the Tony awards while a million people get whacked with machetes. 
I don't believe a billion Indians are going to hell. I don't think we get cancer to learn life lessons, and I don't believe that people die young because God needs another angel. 
I think it's just bullshit, and on some level, I think we all know that, I mean, don't you?... 
Look, I understand that religion makes it easier to deal with all of the random shitty things that happen to us. And I wish I could get on that ride, I'm sure I would be happier. But I can't. Feelings aren't enough. I need it to be real 

Friday, August 16, 2013

Blogger skeptical & compassionate, if unfair toward antitheists. Also, dragons.

Blogger Lindy West, responding to a creationist's argument that dragons were literally real:
Now, I don't personally believe in Satan (or dragons, or demons, or resurrection, or underground pits of eternally burning gay people, or that a guy can build a campfire in a whale's colon), but I don't mind if people do as long as their commitment to literalism remains wholly separate from my country's legislation and scientific progress. I recognize that religious beliefs, institutions, and structured rituals—even ones that seem arbitrary to an outsider—can be extremely fortifying for people, especially communities of people that have been abandoned or demonized by the status quo.
On the one hand, this is a great succinct example of sound and healthy skepticism. On the other hand, West is implicitly throwing critics of religion under the bus (specifically, those critics who do mind if people believe in supernatural entities, and who think that such belief helps to normalize certain undesirable and dangerous attitudes and behaviors).

On the other other hand, she acknowledges the benevolent role religious participation can play in believers' lives, without endorsing said supernaturalism. Two out of three ain't bad! (via Jezebel)

*

And, how could we deprive you of the opportunity to watch a guy argue for the existence of dragons on theological grounds? Here's the video from the Jezebel post:

Monday, August 05, 2013

Photos from the 2013 GBH picnic





Greg Epstein spoke this weekend at the Greater Boston Humanists annual summer cookout, and shared some tantalizing details about the Humanist community center soon to open in Harvard Square for the benefit of all members of the local secular community. (More photos from the event can be seen at Meetup.com)

Monday, July 22, 2013

Friendly Neighborhood Atheist clean-up crew


A photo from our labors this Saturday at the Esplanade clean-up service event organized by Dan Harris of the Secular Society of MIT. Pictured from l-r: Coree N., John T., Joel T., Ozzie the Esplanade Association horticulturist, Dan H., Zachary B., and Jenna D. Three cheers for putting our Values Into Action.

You'll notice our snazzy Friendly Neighborhood Atheist tee-shirts. If you'd like to buy one now, send us an email and we can make the arrangements; they are $20. However, later this month an email will be coming around the Facebook and Meetup mailing lists, with an order form for several new designs. 

Friday, July 05, 2013

Louie's believies

In his feature-length stand-up show "Live at the Beacon Theater," comedian Louis CK makes a frank epistemic confession:
I have a lot of beliefs, and I live by none of them. That's just the way I am. They're just my beliefs. I just like believing them. They're my little believies.
This strikes me as a great way to phrase the universal mismatch between belief and behavior, and needs to be turned into a meme graphic post-haste.

The full show is available on Netflix (the part I quote starts at around 6 minutes in) and may well be on YouTube, too. For more on this subject, see also The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on epistemology, and William Clifford's 1877 essay, "The Ethics of Belief," and my own blogger's teasing-out of a corollary of CK and Clifford's observations.

A corollary from Oscar Wilde: “The value of an idea has nothing whatsoever to do with the sincerity of the man who expresses it.” Contrast this to the wisdom theme of H.P. Lovecraft's tale, “The Call of Cthulhu”: “ he most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents.” If there were a divinity of perfect rationality, would we not have to call this being either insensate as a stone, or wholly mad? (See also Borges' story "Funes the Memorious" for a case example of how a perfect omnimnemonic could not in practice survive with his reason intact, free to live a life we could call human.) --  ZWB

Tuesday, July 02, 2013

QOTW: Atheists as waterfowl

From a March 2012 commentary in Reason by (former MTV VJ) Kennedy:
You can call atheism a belief system [...] or you can make a stronger assertion and say that atheists and theists, who have conveniently developed hate-tinged froth and vitriol for one another, are quacking and waddling in the same way in different ponds. Either way, they are ducks and atheism is a religion. At least it is in the hands of those who are so religious about their disbelief that they place the weight of the argument on the feathery shoulders of their believing brothers and sisters.

Friday, May 24, 2013

Glenn Beck: Pluralism is a competition!

According to Raw Story, Glenn Beck says that “forces of spiritual darkness” (at CNN) arranged to have Wolf Blitzer ask an atheist tornado survivor if she thanked the Lord for sparing her life. The question was just part of a plan to give atheism more airtime, you see. And of course if that's how the atheists are going to be play, well, Beck wants Christians to fight back by showing that they can out-do us in the nice department:
Beck insisted that he liked atheists, but Christians needed to prove that they were better.
“Have I done anything this week, have you done anything that would make anyone say, ‘Wow, what is it about them? I want to be like that. I want to be able to provide hope to others in dark times,’” the radio host said. “If you haven’t done anything different than what an atheist can do this week then your light is not shining very bright at all.”
(Emphasis mine.) Beck's inducement to Christians to prove they are better than atheists is ludicrous... but it sounds even more ridiculous if you trade the terms "atheists" and "Christians" for any pairing that puts mainstream Christianity in the position of underdog, and gives the place of privilege to any other worldview:
Sonja Eggerickx insists that she likes Christians, but says Humanists need to prove that they are superior.
Miroslav Gavrilović insists that he likes Christians, but says the Catholics of the Serbian Orthodox church need to prove that they are superior.
Zachary Bos insists that he likes Christians, but says the secular citizens of Massachusetts need to prove that they are superior. 
Hey, I like that last one! Let's see how much further we can take it:
“Have I done anything this week, have you done anything that would make anyone say, ‘Wow, what is it about those Atheists? I want to be like that. I want to be able to provide compassion and reason to others in dark times,’” Zachary Bos continued. “If you haven’t done anything different than what a theist can do this week then your Atheism is not shining very bright at all.”
I like this game; it is both easy and subversive. Let's keep doing it! Here's how:
  1. Find a piece of sectarian writing that is blind to the privilege of its position
  2. Swap the privileged identity with the underprivileged identity
  3. Share with friends
What do we call this? #tradingprivilege? #POVswap? #flipthebias? 

Thursday, May 16, 2013

Looking for Newton atheists!


From the Secular Coalition for Massachusetts:
There's an event coming up -- the Mayor's Prayer Breakfast -- that the SCMA would like to use as an occasion to talk with various civic leaders about inclusion and SOCAS. If you are a Newton resident who'd be willing to talk with the SCMA about participating in our effort to engage the Mayor's office over this issue, please let us know: massachusetts@secular.org.  
In light of the potential fallout from coming forward as an atheist representative or activist, let us assure you that discretion will be afforded you, as well as anonymity if you require it.

Boston atheists needed to engage mayoral candidates on secular issues!


From the Secular Coalition for Massachusetts:
With the various mayoral candidates' forums coming up, the SCMA would like to know who in Boston would be willing to serve as resident representatives of the local nontheist community. We're going to want to ask the candidates how they intend to represent all Bostonians -- including nontheists -- if they are elected. 
If you are a Boston resident, please let us know if you'd like to be part of the team that puts these questions out there. In light of the potential fallout from coming forward as an atheist representative or activist, let us assure you that discretion will be afforded you, as well as anonymity if you require it. 
Contact: massachusetts@secular.org.

Monday, May 13, 2013

Psychiatrist loses license after diagnosing "evil spirits"

From the Religion Clause blog:
As reported by the Boston Globe, on May 8 the Massachusetts Board of Registration in Medicine suspended the medical license of psychiatrist Raymond W. Kam, saying that his conduct in treating a 16-year old patient last year called into question his competence to practice medicine. Kam last year had already signed a voluntary agreement not to practice medicine. Kam, a Boston Children's Hospital psychiatrist, became convinced that the patient was being hurt by "evil spiritual entities." Kam gave the girl a cross to wear in exchange for a different religious symbol she had on. After the girl was discharged from the hospital, Kam, who had withdrawn from the girl's treatment team, obtained permission from the girl's father to act as her spiritual mentor, taking her to his church and exchanging text messages with her. When the girl was kicked out of her house, Kam offered to let her stay at his house on several occasions. He failed to report to authorities an incident in which the girl's mother pushed her down a flight of stairs and tried to asphyxiate her.  
The state Board also reprimanded a second psychiatrist who had failed to report the girl's abuse to authorities. Kam could regain his license next year if he completes a psychiatric evaluation and enters a 5-year probation agreement.
BA member Gabe McDonald writes:
There far too many instances where faith healing and religious practices are doled out in lieu of modern medical therapy. It is especially unfortunate when such non-treatments are protected by law. Here is a good example of what the repercussions should be.

Tuesday, May 07, 2013

Gingrich: MA gay marriage 'outlaws' Catholic doctrine


From an article by Zack Ford at Thinkprogress:
In an appearance on Meet The Press this weekend, Newt Gingrich reiterated a claim he’s made many times before that Massachusetts’s legalization of marriage equality discriminated against the Catholic Church’s ability to provide adoption services. In this particular appearance, he offered his most exaggerated description of what happened when Catholic Charities in Boston closed its adoption services, claiming that the state “outlawed” Catholic doctrine. 
The essential point of Gingrich's argument: "It is impossible for the Catholic Church to have an adoption service in Massachusetts that follows Catholic doctrine." The essential point of the rebuttal, as put forward by Ford: "Catholic Charities could continue to operate, but if it wants to continue receiving state funding, it has to comply with state laws."

As elsewhere, the supposed cultural conflict between secularization (equal protect and privilege under the law for all persons, regardless of sexual orientation) and religion (here, the Roman Catholic church and one of its charitable initiatives) is a product of misrepresentation rather than irreconcilable values.

Friday, April 19, 2013

Mike Sullivan: Bombing attack a "horrific, cowardly and godless" act


Former United States Attorney Michael Sullivan, a current Republican candidate for US Senate from Massachusetts, told MassLive.com on Tuesday that the Boston bombing was a "horrific, cowardly and godless" act. Thank you to Hemant Mehta for alerting us to the story.

A Secular Coalition for Massachusetts representative spoke with staff in Sullivan's campaign office earlier today, and explained that we'd like to think the candidate failed to realize how his words deepened the hurt of those of us who actually are godless as well as patriotic, ethical, and hurting.

We asked if someone could get back in touch with us by close of business, and emphasized that we're eager to give the candidate the benefit of the doubt. This is hopefully a careless injury, rather than an expression of prejudice, and if that's so it can be remedied with good will, an educational conversation, and a heartfelt apology.

Staffer Bill Rivers told us that the campaign is shut down in light of the today's police activity, and that he doesn't know how long it would take for "a decision" to be made or for that decision to be communicated to us. We'll keep you posted.

How do YOU feel about this comment, and the attitudes it reflects? Let Mike Sullivan know, on Twitter: @MikeSullivanMA. Tag @BostonAtheists and @SecularMass so everyone in our community can join the conversation and lend their perspective.

This is what we tweeted from the Boston Atheists account:
@MikeSullivanMA, we're concerned you don't know how your comment about Monday's 'horrific, cowardly and godless' attack deepens our hurt.
The Secular Coalition for Massachusetts is also alert to the situation:
@MikeSullivanMA Please don't associate nontheism with terrorism. The godless people of MA are hurt and grieving too.

Thursday, April 18, 2013

Humanist asks: "Am I not a resident of this city?"

From a Patheos post by James Croft, a Research and Education Fellow at the Humanist Community at Harvard:
At times such as this, when a spirit of solidarity and mutual support is essential, it is critical that any publicly-sanctioned expression of grief, any public ritual to heal the psychic wounds of terror, be completely inclusive of all people. Any public response which privileges one religious view above any other, or which excludes anybody due to their beliefs, could add insult to injury, making them feel other, not part of the society which is struggling to put itself together again. [. . .] there is no excuse – no excuse whatsoever - for the divisive, exclusive, and insulting “interfaith” service which President Obama today attended alongside the dignitaries of Boston at Holy Cross Cathedral. The program is almost exclusively Christian, with nods given to Jewish and Muslim representatives. All the readings are from the Judeo-Christian tradition. There are prayers aplenty. The Processional is Praise to the Lord, Almighty
I am not one of those atheists who is allergic to religion. In fact I often find religious ceremonies moving and powerful. Often, I am happy to attend. But this is a publicly-sanctioned, widely-reported service advertised by the State as “an opportunity for the community to come together in the wake of the tragic events at the Boston Marathon”. It is being attended by the Governor and the President himself. It is the symbolic response to the attacks: the seal of the state adorns the program, and the service is called “Healing Our City”. Yet it completely excludes many Bostonians: those who are not religious, and those whose religions are not represented in the program. This is not a service I would choose to attend even given my love of ritual and ceremony, and my deep need to process what has just happened: I wouldn’t feel safe there. I wouldn’t feel respected. Nothing on that program speaks to me, makes me feel I’m wanted as part of this society. Am I not a resident of this city? Am I to be denied healing?

On why we couldn't have been invited to the Boston Marathon interfaith service

A statement from Josiah Van Vliet, President of the Boston Atheists:

This week a secular event in a very secular city was visited by a terrible human tragedy. And in response to this nationally significant event a service was coordinated; a service where the representatives of many different belief systems would be given the chance to speak to their own people and on behalf of their perspective. At this service the non-theistic perspective was not given voice. And I think it is our responsibility to fix what made this outcome inevitable.

It should be noted that the representatives of the secular perspective did every bit of outreach they could have to get us a seat at the table. I know personally several of the people who worked on this and there is no additional amount of leg work that could have made a difference. What we (as non-theists) needed was to have had different relationship with the country at large. And there are two things that I think we need in place for next time.

First we need to have a creed that outsiders can understand. I mean creed here like mission statement, not an object of faith. We need a few sentences that sound nice that can be “what we are about”. These few sentences would be public relations and not gospel. It would be important to get them right, to have them be something that we feel comfortable supporting, but not something that needed to be perfect. It would serve as the greeting card from atheism to the country; something to help us introducing ourselves to people who still just think that we are satanic communists.

Secondly we need representatives. We need people that our community has endorsed, who speak for us and to us in times of tragedy and celebration. Again we can’t wait for the perfect person who everyone got along with about everything, but someone to say what many of us are thinking, so that we can feel that we are heard. These representatives would not be telling the world what we as individuals think, we the represented would not be obliged to agree with, believe, or follow what is said. But like having a politician you voted for speak, they would be our stand in for the public conversation

Having such a public persona and publicly understood mission statement would have made our representation at the upcoming interfaith service possible. Without establishing our public presence in a “day in day out” way, any time we want to be included is going to look like a shocking introduction that will make our inclusion about us “suddenly” being included. We need to be talked about as just another identity of Americans in an ongoing basis so that people get used to us being out and proud. And having a recognizable secular persona who isn’t known for confrontation would make that person’s inclusion in an interfaith service make sense. Someone needs to be out there talking about our community’s perspective in a way that gives us voice without making us look like bomb throwers. Hitchens, Dawkins and Harris are great and have done great things for the Atheist position, but I’m not sure they have done much good for the atheist community.

We have enough debaters; I think we need a communicator.

So what I am suggesting here is that we start to put ourselves forward in a positive way. I am not saying that we forcibly retire Dawkins, or cease to criticize where criticism is necessary. Just that we also start to engage with the majority of our country, which is religious. Religions and religious people are here to stay, but so are we. And when tragedy strikes, it would help if we were already seen as the important part of the American fabric that we already are.

Boston secular groups join community response to tragedy

From http://bostonatheists.org/news

Boston’s nontheists have been working to help those affected in Monday’s bomb attack. The Secular Coalition for America, the Boston Atheists, and the HumanistCommunity at Harvard are local sponsors of a secular fundraising effort with the group the We Are Atheism, which has raised over $20,000 to assist victims. $10,000 of this money has already been pledged to the One Boston Fund.

Members of the Harvard Humanists have additionally played a lead role in raising over $140,000 for a fund to help two individuals with ties to their community who suffered severe injuries.

Josiah Van Vliet, President of the Boston Atheists, said “I want to reach out to all those who do not have a church or a pastor, to tell them: You are not alone, and that there are others like you out here. We are also upset, and scared. Although your viewpoint may not be expressed at a prayer vigil, it is one that it shared and sympathized with throughout the country.”

Georgina Capetillo, Boston Atheists Director of Diversity, agreed. “In the wake of tragedy, it’s important that atheists be included in a positive way. We are all part of one community, and we sympathize with the victims of the attacks no less than any Americans.”

Scott Romanowski is an organizer with the Atheists of Greater Lowell, one of the partner organizations of the Secular Coalition for Massachusetts. He said, “In tragedies like this all Americans, secular or not, come together to help each other. We can work to prevent such violence, we must also be ready to respond in a unified way when our community suffers a tragedy like this.

“Our hearts go out to the victims, their families and to all of those affected by this senseless act of violence,” said Edwina Rogers, Executive Director of the Secular Coalition for America, of which the Secular Coalition for Massachusetts is a state chapter.

Plans are being made for a secular memorial service—a gathering for those disinclined to attend an event organized under a religious or inter-faith banner—to take place in Boston this weekend. An announcement with the time and location will be posted to Secular Coalition for Massachusetts social media pages.

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

Local interfaith efforts profiled in HuffPo


From an article by Jaweed Kaleem, profiling a few of the ways Boston's ethical communities are responding variously to the Monday attack, with prayer vigils, special services, fundraising, and so on: B
In Boston, home to some of the nation's oldest churches and one where a stroll on any given street block often includes passing historic Protestant congregations, churches have also reported opening for shelter to house displaced residents or out-of-towners visiting for the marathon, as well announced plans to offer counseling. The Islamic Society of Boston Cultural Center has said it has relief volunteers and counselors available, while Temple Israel of Boston, a Jewish congregation, will also open Tuesday for a prayer vigil. 
The Boston Atheists and the Secular Coalition for Massachusetts have also voiced their support for victims, saying that although "prayer isn’t for us an option," differences in religious beliefs "pale in comparison to what brings us all together as members of the community."

"Victim in bomb attack humbled by ‘raw humanity’"


A small bit of uplifting testimony, from an article in the Boston Herald quoting a victim of Monday's bombing:
“Raw humanity at the core has the ability to be kind and helpful if we would just let it” [...] 
Erickson was lucky to have not one, but two guardian angels on her side. A woman at the Mandarin Hotel comforted Erickson until medics were able to get her to treatment. That woman later texted a touching message. 
“Helping me, helped her, and it was just amazing,” said Erickson. “That happened all over and it’s very humbling. It’s very humbling, and I hope we all can learn from this.”

#ActForBoston


In order to help facilitate the participation of our members in the larger community response, we are encouraging Twitter users to use hashtags like #ActForBoston rather than #PrayForBoston. We're further more emphasizing the need to set aside divisive topics so that we can all focus on the matter at hand: the need to act in solidarity, and with compassion, to react constructively to this act of senseless violence.

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

A vigil tonight at Harvard


A vigil has been organized this evening for the Harvard-wide community, at 8 PM on the steps of Memorial Church in Harvard Yard. Members of the larger community, beyond Harvard, are welcome to join the vigil.

This is an opportunity to stand in solidarity as members of a united community. Even when our searching doesn't come up with an explanation for the kinds of violent and tragic events as our city saw yesterday, the act of coming together can bring us comfort.

Share the event link on Facebook and Meetup

Atheists -- from Boston & elsewhere -- raise money for support fund

Over 150 people were injured and 3 died in yesterday's tragic act of violence. The secular community, like all segments of society, has expressed its wish to help; the team at We Are Atheism has set up a fund under their Atheists Giving Aid program, to help us do just that.

Atheists Giving Aid exists to respond in tragedies like this and provide a resource for non-believers (and others) to give money that will make it to the victims and their families without passing through religious affiliated organizations. You can safely donate knowing that no religious condition or message will be associated with your act of charity.

Atheists Giving Aid raised over $25,000 from secular donors for the victims of the Sandy Hook Massacre, in Newtown, CT; this time, monies will be disbursed to parties who were affected  by the violence in Boston.

Americans are resilient. We'll be okay. But, bills still have to be paid. This is where you come it. Give what you can. Share this page: http://www.weareatheism.com/donate/atheists-giving-aid-boston-marathon-tragedy. Let people know there is a way they can give.

The organizers of We Are Atheism are actively pursuing their 501(c)3 status so your donations ARE tax deductible. Help those affected by this while also showing that atheists care as much or more than any religious group out there. We don't give money to churches every week, so let's dig deep in your pockets for this cause.

To donate, visit the support fund page at WeAreAtheism.com.

As of the time of this posting, the current fund total is over $8,500, of which more than $500 came directly from Boston Atheists members (including Howard S., Bill S., Maria G., Andre B., Turner H., Nick G., Jenni K., Jim B., and others...).

The Boston Atheists are the local contact for this We Are Atheism campaign; the campaign is also being sponsored by the Secular Coalition for Massachusetts and the Humanist Community at Harvard.

How to help in times of disaster

In response to inquiries from our members as to how to respond constructively when events like this happen in our community, we offer the following suggestions:

  • Offer to babysit for friends or neighbors who because of today’s events would be helped by such support
  • Sign up for the Red Cross aid appeals mailing list
  • As requested by the Boston Police Department, call 1-800-494-TIPS if you have relevant information
  • Prepare yourself and your family for unexpected crises. Be informed, make a plan, build a kit: www.ready.gov
  • Train to help yourself and others. CERT training and First Aid/CPR Training are great ways to build up your tool kit so that you can productively contribute when an emergency, large or small, arises
If you have more time, talent, or resources to contribute, you can find a national-level organization to volunteer with that compliments your situation:
Check with your state and local volunteer fire department, law enforcement, or emergency management office for more opportunities. Thanks to Lt. Col. Edward Bos, Emergency Services Officer, Alaska Wing CAP, for his advice in compiling these suggestions.

Concerning the Marathon Monday tragedy

For public distribution. Tuesday, 04/16/2013 -- 9:00
from the Boston Atheists news page (pdf)


A statement following the tragic events of the Boston Marathon explosions, from the leaders of the Secular Coalition for Massachusetts and the Boston Atheists.

"We know that we’re not alone among atheists and other secular people in wanting to show sympathy and support in response to today’s tragedy. Although prayer isn’t for us an option, we are ready to help by working with the Red Cross and other emergency and community organizations in any way possible.

"Leaders of local secular organizations like the Boston Atheists and the Secular Coalition for Massachusetts have been diligently monitoring communications for any opportunity to respond constructively to the tragic events of the day. We may have a different religious perspective, but on days like today, those differences pale in comparison to what brings us all together as members of the community.

"Our thanks go to the first responders and other support staff who came to the aid of the victims in Copley Square today, and who have been working since then to protect our safety. Above all, our thoughts and compassion are with the victims and their families."

Signed,

Zachary Bos
Co-chair, Secular Coalition for Massachusetts
Massachusetts State Director, American Atheists
Immediate past president, Boston Atheists

Ellery Schempp
Co-chair, Secular Coalition for Massachusetts

Josiah Van Vliet
President, Boston Atheists



About the BA: The Boston Atheists is the largest atheist membership organization in New England, and one of the most active secular organizations in the Boston area. We provide opportunities for friendship, education, and community for hundreds of local atheists and, as a local affiliate of American Atheists, advocate for the advancement of reality-based worldviews. Twitter | Meetup

About the SC-MA: The mission of the Secular Coalition for Massachusetts, a state chapter of the Secular Coalition for America, is to increase visibility of and respect for nontheistic viewpoints, and to pstrengthen the secular character of our government as the best guarantee of freedom for all Americans. Facebook | Twitter | Webpage

Saturday, February 02, 2013

That guy in the subway with the sign and the Chick tracts


From the Boston Phoenix, a 2006 article by Camille Dodero about one of Boston's most widely seen street ministers:
Bob Whetstone may be the most famous man in Boston whom nobody knows. A lanky 57-year-old with oval glasses, a flat-brimmed trucker hat, and the perpetual tan of someone who works outside, he was so recognizable loitering on Brookline Avenue this past Friday that in just 30 minutes at least five different fans heading to the Red Sox game responded to Whetstone with a riot of pointed fingers, disbelieving guffaws, and I-see-him-everywhere whispers. Said one passerby in a pre-game-partying slur: “It’s that Jesus guy!”
Whetstone is a walking advertisement for Christian salvation — or, more precisely, a bipedal fire-and-brimstone anti-advertisement for not choosing said salvation. A congregant of the First Baptist Church in Chelsea, Whetstone doesn’t yell, shout, or preach — although his hat does scream heaven or hell/it’s your choice! Instead, he roams the streets wearing a large, vibrant sandwich board that indelicately illustrates the transition between earthly life and eternal life, complete with a pristine cross-shaped bridge traversing the scorching depths of hell and leading to the bright, happy-looking land of heaven.
Whetstone stands outside nearly every local professional sports game and every major concert, quietly brandishing these signs and passing out literature. He plans his music schedule by, uh, reading the Phoenix. “I mark all the concerts on a calendar — I got them all lined up for a couple months in advance,” he says. When there isn’t a special event during the day, he’ll roam around the subway or wander around Faneuil Hall. “I do anything with a crowd — doesn’t matter what it is.” When there are competing events, Whetstone will pray to the Lord, “Which do you want me to go to first, second, third?” He does this six days a week — at least. “Sometimes I don’t go on Monday if there’s not much going on,” he says. “You gotta take one day and slack off if you can.” Whetstone goes to Miami Beach every winter, he says, and stands outside clubs with a nine-volt-battery-powered hat that lights up the word repent. In the summer, he hangs around Hampton and Old Orchard Beaches.
Whetstone calls this his “mission.” His only boss is God. But God doesn’t pay him in the traditional sense. “I live by faith,” he claims. “I have no income, nothing from anybody — churches, government, anybody. Zero, absolutely zero.”
How do you —
“I pray to God,” he interrupts.
What about dinner tonight?
“When I go down to Quincy Market, there’re Christians down there,” he says. “They want me to eat there. They actually ask me to eat there.” Whetstone wants it known that he is no beggar. “I don’t ask for anything. You can follow me around for ten years and you’ll see I don’t ask for a penny. God brings everything to me.”
He says God brought him a car. His glasses. The Old Navy sweatshirt on his back. He’s vague about the details of how, exactly, God provided him with these things — and equally vague about where he lives, though he talks about having resided in churches and vans. And so while it seems almost unbelievable that a man can survive in Boston without a consistent paycheck — never mind that he winters in Miami Beach — he does wear that same Old Navy sweatshirt again and again.
Whetstone says that in June of 1993 the Lord told him to quit his job as a security guard on the North Shore to minister on the streets full-time. Previously, after having been born again at age 29 and moving to Massachusetts from Pennsylvania for Bible college, he’d worked as a chaplain and spent years rounding up people on buses for Bible classes on the North Shore. But he wasn’t initially thrilled about this new divine assignment. “I argued with God for two weeks before I finally started doing it,” Whetstone admits. “If I didn’t do it, then I was disobeying Him, and I don’t want to disobey God —”
“I keep seeing you!” interrupts a male passerby.
“Jesus loves you,” says Whetstone, offering a tract. “This is Good Friday, the day Jesus died for our sins.”
Whetstone says that the most difficult part of his “calling” is being single. “I could’ve got married a couple times. But if I’m going to be a husband, I can’t just have a woman put some food on the table and not be there.” He pauses. “That’s been the only thing, really, that’s been hard for me. Because, you know” — he swallows hard — “I’m a normal man.”
Right now, Whetstone is undertaking the normal-man act of checking his watch. He’s late for Faneuil Hall, then he’s coming back here to catch Sox fans leaving the game, then hitting some theaters “if I have time.” But right now he really has to go. When your boss is God, being late is not an option.